← Back to Track Record

Game 2: Boston vs New York Y

Sports Β· Kalshi Β· Called NO, verified WIN Β· Oct 1, 2026
View the original Kalshi market →
Verified Outcome
WIN
PillarLab called Boston will NOT win (NO @ 5%).
Result: Boston did not win. The call was correct. Final result: New York Y won.
Analyzed: Oct 1, 2026, 2:09 AM UTC
Market resolved: Oct 1, 2026, 3:21 AM UTC
Called 1h before resolution. The call was made before the outcome was known.

https://kalshi.com/markets/kxmlbgame/professional-baseball-game/kxmlbgame-26sep302000bosnyy

PillarLab
πŸ“‘ Fetching Kalshi data...
PillarLab
βœ… Got data from Kalshi API!0.5s
PillarLab
πŸ” Step 1: Detecting market type and category...
PillarLab
βœ… Category: ⚽ SPORTS βœ… Type: BINARY πŸ“Š Market: Game 2: Boston vs New York Y πŸ“… Date: 2026-10-01T00:00:00.000Z πŸ’° Volume: $10,676,786 Current Odds: β€’ New York Y: 95% β€’ Boston: 5%0.9s
PillarLab
⏳ Step 2: Gathering intelligence (parallel)...
PillarLab
βœ… Intelligence gathered: Vegas Lines Β· Injury Report Β· Team Stats Β· Reddit Sentiment Β· Candidate Dossiers (case for + case against, every candidate β‰₯2%)5.1s
PillarLab
🧠 Step 3: Deep Analysing across all 9 pillars β€” hang tight, ~20s...
PillarLab

πŸ“Š Market Summary

⚽ Game 2: Boston vs New York Y

Team/PlayerCurrent Odds
New York Y95%
Boston5%

2 options total

PillarLab

🎯 Best Trade

  • Action: Boston β€” NO @ 5%

  • Confidence: 🟑 MEDIUM Β· Uncertainty: LOW

  • Why:

  • Boston trails 0-1 after a 9-0 blowout loss in which they managed zero runs and just two hits.
  • Boston's starter Sonny Gray posted a 4.90 ERA in his last Yankee stint in 2018, and his edge against his ex-club is unproven in this spot.
  • Boston has scored two runs or fewer in four of the last five meetings against New York, showing a persistent offensive struggle in this matchup.
  • The situational path is brutal: on the road, facing elimination, against a team that has covered the run line in three straight head-to-head games.
PillarLab

πŸ“ˆ Where the Market Stands

OptionMarketRead
New York Y95%βšͺ FAIR
Boston5%βšͺ FAIR

Verdicts compare my own read against the market price β€” 🟒 UNDERPRICED (market has it too low) Β· πŸ”΄ OVERPRICED (market has it too high). The analysis below is the why.

PillarLab

πŸ”¬ 9-Pillar Analysis (Sharp Trading Method)

πŸ“Š 1. Vegas Line

My Vegas Line reads New York as a heavy favorite in Game 2, with a projected 5-2 Yankees win and a run line that has covered in three straight against Boston, though no moneyline price is published to convert into an exact implied probability.

πŸ“ˆ 2. PillarScore

New York's recent form is genuinely strong β€” a 9-0 Game 1 win with Schlittler striking out 11 over 6 1/3 shutout innings and Rice driving in six β€” while Boston has scored two runs or fewer in four of the last five meetings, so the form edge clearly belongs to New York and agrees with the market price.

πŸ₯ 3. Injury Report

Aaron Judge is on the 10-Day IL with a leg injury (.241/.360/.511, 18 HR, 41 RBI), a real loss for New York, but Boston's injury picture is murkier with an unnamed player referenced as quitting mid-game due to injury, and the probable starters are Sonny Gray for Boston and Max Fried for New York.

πŸ“± 4. Reddit Sentiment

Reddit sentiment is fragmented β€” one r/sportsbook post notes the Yankees 'start slow without Judge,' while Boston fans criticize their own players for quitting after two at-bats β€” with no clear consensus pick or sharp take for Game 2, so there is no crowd hype to fade.

πŸ”’ 5. Team Stats & Form

New York's recent results are better than their price implies, not worse: they own MLB's fourth-best ATS record at 88-74, have covered the run line in three straight against Boston, and the Over has hit in 11 straight Yankees games facing the AL at night, while Boston's bats have been cold in this matchup.

🌀️ 6. Situational Factors

Boston has the worst situational path: they trail 0-1 in a best-of-three after a 9-0 blowout, are on the road again at Yankee Stadium, and teams that win Game 1 of this format win the series 88% of the time, leaving Boston with minimal margin for error.

πŸ”€ 7. Line Movement

No opening-vs-current line movement data is published for this game, and for a single MLB playoff game the moneyline history is not typically surfaced in the gathered intelligence, so the neutral read is that the current prices show no visible drift.

⏰ 8. Time Decay

LOW - the main pending item is the full extent of New York's injury list beyond Judge, but with Judge already priced in and Boston's own injury situation unnamed, there is little fresh news likely to move the price before first pitch.

⚑ 9. Contrarian Check

The main contrarian risk is that Boston starts Sonny Gray, a former All-Star with a stated edge against his ex-club, and New York is without Judge, so a single good Gray start could flip a game the market treats as nearly decided.

PillarLab

⚠️ Disclaimer: AI can make mistakes. This is not financial advice. Do your own research before placing any trades.

Stop guessing. See the edge.

Paste any Kalshi or Polymarket market. PillarLab runs a full 9-pillar analysis and hands you a Best Trade call in about 30 seconds.

Free to start Β· 10 credits Β· no card

PillarLab AI is an AI prediction-market analyzer that runs a 9-pillar analysis on Kalshi and Polymarket markets and publishes a public, settlement-verified track record of its decisive calls.

PillarLab AI
PillarLab
9-Pillar Analysis ~30s

#1 AI-Powered Prediction Market Analyzer Tool for Kalshi & Polymarket

Paste any market URL for a full 9-pillar analysis: Vegas lines, injury reports, weather forecasts, sentiment, edge vs market, and a Best Trade call.

How it works

Paste a Kalshi or Polymarket URL β†’ AI fetches real-time API market data β†’ 4–5 parallel intelligence sources β†’ a deep 9-pillar analysis β†’ an actionable prediction with an edge estimate. 5 market categories: Politics, Sports, Weather, Finance and General.

⚽ Sports (9 Pillars)

  1. 1.Vegas Lines β†’ spread, moneyline, totals
  2. 2.Line Movement β†’ sharp money signals
  3. 3.Injury Reports β†’ player status tracking
  4. 4.Reddit Sentiment β†’ r/sportsbook consensus
  5. 5.Team Statistics β†’ form, H2H, splits
  6. 6.Situational Factors β†’ rest, travel, schedule
  7. 7.Handle Splits β†’ public vs sharp money
  8. 8.Time Decay β†’ late line movement
  9. 9.Contrarian Check β†’ fade-the-public value

🌦️ Weather (9 Pillars)

  1. 1.Forecast Consensus β†’ GFS / ECMWF / NWS agreement
  2. 2.Ensemble Spread β†’ GEFS uncertainty range
  3. 3.Forecast Skill Decay β†’ accuracy vs time horizon
  4. 4.Historical Base Rate β†’ NOAA climate frequency
  5. 5.Model Divergence β†’ where models disagree vs market
  6. 6.Micro-Climate Bias β†’ station-specific effects
  7. 7.Storm Track β†’ NHC cone / hurricane tracking
  8. 8.Market Pricing β†’ implied probability vs forecast
  9. 9.Contrarian Check β†’ overshoot / mean-reversion

πŸ’° Finance (9 Pillars)

  1. 1.Technical Analysis β†’ RSI, MACD, support levels
  2. 2.Fundamental Metrics β†’ P/E, revenue, earnings
  3. 3.Smart Money β†’ institutional flows, insider trades
  4. 4.Reddit Sentiment β†’ WSB, r/stocks analysis
  5. 5.Macro Indicators β†’ Fed rates, inflation, GDP
  6. 6.News Catalysts β†’ earnings, product launches
  7. 7.Social Velocity β†’ Twitter momentum tracking
  8. 8.Market Signals β†’ volume, bid-ask analysis
  9. 9.Contrarian Check β†’ overcrowded trade detection

πŸ“° General (9 Pillars)

  1. 1.Base Rate β†’ historical frequency analysis
  2. 2.Official Benchmarks β†’ expert forecasts
  3. 3.Reddit Sentiment β†’ subreddit consensus
  4. 4.Social Velocity β†’ viral momentum tracking
  5. 5.News Recency β†’ 24–72h breaking news
  6. 6.Source Quality β†’ credibility scoring
  7. 7.Time Decay β†’ resolution timeline
  8. 8.Contrarian Check β†’ hidden edge detection

πŸ›οΈ Politics (9 Pillars)

  1. 1.Polls Analysis β†’ polling vs market odds divergence
  2. 2.Economic Impact β†’ GDP, unemployment affecting votes
  3. 3.Approval Ratings β†’ candidate favorability tracking
  4. 4.Cross-Platform Markets β†’ Polymarket vs Kalshi arbitrage
  5. 5.Breaking News β†’ events shifting political odds
  6. 6.Regional Patterns β†’ swing state analysis
  7. 7.Social Sentiment β†’ Reddit, X political trends
  8. 8.Data Uncertainty β†’ confidence intervals
  9. 9.Contrarian Risk β†’ devil's advocate view